Thoughts from the ICCI Forum on Hog Confinements
October 16, 2008 by dannycarroll
The organization known as Iowa Citizens for Community Improvement (ICCI) held a candidate forum last night in Montezuma, Iowa. Approximately 60 people were in attendance. The main topic of discussion dealt with the regulation of confinement livestock feeding operations (CAFO’s). As most Iowans are aware livestock management and production techniques have changed considerably over the last 20 to 30 years. This has resulted in the concentration of animals in fewer and fewer facilities. The odor often associated with these operations is obviously objectionable to neighbors. On the other hand Iowa is well suited to grain and livestock production. Thousands of jobs are associated with this industry and billions of dollars in our local and state economy. Lawmakers and other officials have been wrestling with the control and regulation of livestock production operations since 1995.
The first question last night asked the political candidates in attendance (State Representative Eric Palmer chose without explanation, not to attend) their views on local county control versus state control of CAFO’s. I offered that counties did not have the staff and resources necessary to regulate such an industry. Moreover they would have to look to the IDNR for consistent environmental protection guidelines which would essentially defer decisions back to the state. State wide regulation and environmental protection, in my opinion is the only way to go.
I also observed that it is too bad the issue has become so polarized. Iowans have in the past and can in this situation come together and negotiate the location and sound management of livestock facilities. Although I am not on the same page as many members of ICCI I found the discussion last night very respectful and productive. If I am elected on November 4th I look forward to working with the ICCI folks in Poweshiek County and local livestock producers in fostering a positive relationship that serves both the needs of farmers and other rural residents.
Danny Carroll